Custom Cookies by Sarah M

Custom Cookies started in 2017 when owner Sarah Mentzer was approached about making 500 turtle cookies to help out an event. She took on the challenge and word quickly spread. Soon Sarah was making custom cookies for parties, celebrations, and unique events of friends, neighbors and organizations around the Akron area.

Cookie Charcuterie Tray

$45.00

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

$35.00

Seasonal Decorated Sugar Cookies

$36.00

Sugar Dipped Minis

$22.00

The rest of Custom Cookies' Story

Custom Cookies started in 2017 when owner Sarah Mentzer was approached about making 500 turtle cookies to help out an event. She took on the challenge and word quickly spread. Soon Sarah was making custom cookies for parties, celebrations, and unique events of friends, neighbors and organizations around the Akron area. Today, Sarah delivers 50 to 60 dozen cookies each week out of her home, some standard cookie trays, but most hand-decorated, custom orders made unique for each special occasion.


Sarah has more than 15 years of experience in the food industry and has taught many cooking classes. While baking was not her focus early on, she says her business is her passion, and fills a need that had not been met, both in making any event special and providing a completely custom product. Her goal? Making people smile.

BACK TO TOP